Wednesday, June 19, 2019

Baseball fans prefer freedom over free parking

It was Free Parking Tuesday for the Oakland A’s game and thousands of baseball fans instead opted to park their cars – and behinds – elsewhere to watch, I don’t know … Ellen’s Game of Games instead?
A paid crowd of only 14,310 showed up in a more than half empty stadium to watch the A’s belt six home runs in 16-2 win that took only 2 ½ hours to play. That’s getting big bang for your buck, people, but why did not more A’s fans take advantage of it and flock to the Coliseum like those nose-diving sea gulls?
What’s their excuse? The fans, not the sea gulls.
Well, the A’s opponents were the last-place Baltimore Orioles, who have morphed into the American League’s version the Washington Generals. Watching Chris Davis being fooled by yet another curve ball and striking out again is akin to the Meadowlark Lemon’s string-in-the-ball trick at the free throw line. It’s comical, but it gets old.
It was also Team Swim Night, a promotion that perhaps left A’s fans feeling awkward and slightly uncomfortable, knowing they might risk sitting next to someone in a Speedo whose idea of a seventh-inning stretch is to slap and snap their own muscles.
Or maybe A’s fans wanted the team to spring for free tickets, too. Well, on StubHub a few hours before first pitch, there were tickets available as low as $10 and, for just $30 apiece, there were two tickets next to the A’s dugout for sale. Thirty dollars?! Next to the home team’s dugout!? You can’t get standing room only tickets at Fenway Park for that price.
In all fairness the crowd of 14,000 plus on Free Parking Tuesday looked closer to 24,000 plus because it was so spread out line confetti on a windy day. But, for whatever reason, A’s fans in particular and baseball fans in general are finding something else to spend their time this summer and I doubt it’s staying up to watch the Match Game.
This not unusual in the San Francisco Bay Area where the so-called distractions – wineries, concerts, parks, museums, festivals, restaurants, protests in the streets, romantic walks on the beach, sightseeing sightseers on the Golden Gate Bridge  – overwhelm reasons to attract baseball fans to a ballpark.
The A’s however are not the only team struggling at the turnstiles. Their Bay Area neighbor, the San Francisco Giants, this season have dropped from fourth to 11th in Major League Baseball attendance and they may need a parachute soon. In fact, there is an outside chance that neither the Giants or A’s will both draw at least two millions fans to their home parks this year. That hasn’t happened since 1996 even when the Giants had Barry Bonds and the A’s had Mark McGwire and still couldn’t attract big crowds.
Of course, in 1996, the Giants were still playing in fan unfriendly Candlestick Park but Bonds that season had a 40 home run/40 stolen base year. The Giants, though, went 68-94, finished 23 games of first place and drew only 1,413,922 fans. The big splash the Giants made that year was introducing Lou Seal, its new mascot.
Meanwhile, in Oakland in 1996, McGuire led the majors with 52 home runs yet only 1,148,380 fans paid to see him and his teammates in the Coliseum. The A’s went 78-84 and finished 12 games out of first in their division.
The A’s, this season, have a winning record and they are talented enough to win a wild card playoff berth so long as the Rays come back to reality and the Red Sox don’t get hot. Still, the A’s have no superstars that radiate on a national scale. For example, when the A’s played the Orioles on April 8 in Baltimore, only 6,585 people showed up in beautiful Camden Yards. That `O’ fronting Orioles is now a 0. As in zero.
The assumption is A’s fans will gaggle – or gondola -- to their new ballpark, but they have been talking about building a new one for two decades and they haven’t even broken ground on the latest site. The Atlanta Braves have played in three different ballparks in the time the A’s have taken to build a new one and that might happen in 2023 when Oprah Winfrey is president.
A new ballpark did wonders for the Giants’ franchise, drawing more than three million fans in the 17 of the past 19 seasons. The Giants, currently in last place, still have mainstays and star attractions in Buster Posey and Madison Bumgarner (or Bum-goner assuming he is traded next month) to lure fans to their ballpark-by-the-sea. But both fan bases are not showing up regularly, witness the lack of All-Star Game ballot box stuffing. Not one A’s or Giants player was listed in the Top 5 at any position in the latest MLB All-Star Game voting.
A true test of the Bay Area baseball barometer will come on August 13-14 when the A’s cross the Bay Bridge to play the Giants at newly renamed Oracle Park. Both fan bases will have something to gain and glean from each other then. Giants fans will see what the A’s have done to contend for a playoff spot building through the draft, homegrown talent, and some smart trades. A’s fans ought to find plenty of affordable and available seats at Oracle Park and see what a new ballpark can do for a franchise -- when Parking Free Tuesdays become a thing of the past.